More than three months after Premier Foods announced plans to shutter its Fruit Products Western Cape (FPWC) cannery in Tulbagh, the stone fruit harvest has officially begun with affected farmers still waiting for finalized written agreements.
In a joint media statement issued on 18 November 2026, AgriSA, Agri Western Cape, and the Canning Fruit Producers’ Association (CFPA) called on Premier to immediately receive and pay for this season’s contracted canning fruit while preserving growers’ rights under existing multi-year supply agreements.
Sunk Costs and an Early Harvest
When Premier initiated Section 189 consultations in early August, industry leaders warned that closing a 55,000- to 60,000-tonne processing facility just ahead of the season would shift unmanageable commercial risk onto producers. By mid-November, with picking already underway, sunk production costs have climbed to an estimated 70% of annual expenses—equivalent to roughly R156,000 per hectare at industry benchmark figures.
Nature has further tightened the deadline. Unseasonably early ripening has pushed the harvest forward by up to two weeks in parts of the Western Cape:
- Calitzdorp: Apricot picking commenced on 9 November.
- Robertson: First deliveries began eight days earlier than last year.
- Contractual Limbo: Despite perishable fruit already coming off the trees, affected growers reported that they were still waiting for individual written agreements when harvesting began.
“Breaking even on investments in orchards takes years. Once the fruit ripens, growers have only days to harvest and deliver it,” said AgriSA CEO Johann Kotzé.
The Settlement Shortfall
While Premier indicated in August that it would compensate farmers for contracted incoming fruit, the financial terms of those payouts have become a major flashpoint. According to Premier, the company has reached settlement agreements with 82 peach farmers covering more than 20,000 tonnes of fruit and R67 million in payments.
However, agricultural bodies warn that the numbers leave growers deeply underwater. Premier’s cash settlement offer of R3,250 per tonne for undelivered peaches amounts to R123,500 per hectare at the industry benchmark yield of 38 tonnes per hectare. Against the R156,000 per hectare already spent to bring the crop to harvest, producers face an estimated shortfall of R32,500 per hectare.
The Battle Over Arbitration
Beyond the immediate financial deficit, the CFPA says Premier’s three proposed settlement options required growers to surrender their rights and settle claims under their existing supply agreements.
The dispute has already spilled into court. During recent court proceedings, Premier offered to receive, grade, transport, and pay for five applicant growers’ fruit while preserving their contractual rights, subject to a process of arbitration and a separate undertaking covering potential losses. Yet, when the CFPA requested that Premier extend that exact same arbitration process to other affected growers, the company declined.
AgriSA, Agri Western Cape, and the CFPA are now urging Premier to finalise written agreements for the current harvest immediately, while preserving producers’ rights to resolve the broader contractual dispute through the arbitration process set out in their original agreements.
Agricultural Sector Rallies to Stop Tulbagh Cannery Shutdown